When LeBron James signed with the Los Angeles Lakers in the summer of 2018, the move was viewed as much bigger than basketball. It was about Hollywood, business opportunities, family, and the next phase of his life. After eight straight Finals appearances and another remarkable postseason run with Cleveland, he wanted to choose where to live rather than simply chasing the best basketball situation.
Eight years later, though, it’s fair to wonder whether he underestimated just how much elite basketball he still had left.
LeBron wasn’t nearing the end of his career in 2018. He was entering one of the most unprecedented aging curves the NBA has ever seen.
At 33 years old, he had just averaged 27.5 points, 9.1 assists, and 8.6 rebounds while leading one of the weakest Finals teams of the modern era through the Eastern Conference. He played all 82 regular-season games, logged over 41 minutes per game during the playoffs, and still looked like the league’s most complete player. Most stars are already beginning their decline by that age. LeBron wasn’t.
The problem is that nobody, not even LeBron himself, could have reasonably expected him to remain an All-NBA caliber player for another eight seasons.
If he had known that he would still be averaging around 25 points per game at age 40 and remain one of the league’s premier offensive engines, it’s difficult to imagine him choosing the same destination.
The Lakers simply weren’t built to maximize the years he still had.
The Lakers Were Not Ready to Win
The roster LeBron joined in 2018 was filled with intriguing young players, but very little proven production.
The core consisted of young prospects who still needed years of development. There was talent, but there wasn’t championship infrastructure.
The front office immediately doubled down on questionable roster construction.
Instead of surrounding LeBron with shooting and high-level role players, they added non-shooting veterans such as Lance Stephenson, Rajon Rondo, JaVale McGee, and Michael Beasley. The team lacked spacing, consistent perimeter defense, and offensive cohesion.
Before LeBron’s groin injury on Christmas Day, the Lakers looked respectable. Afterward, the season unraveled, and they ultimately missed the playoffs entirely.
For arguably the greatest player in basketball history, wasting an MVP-level season at age 34 was a massive opportunity cost.
The Championship Came, But It Wasn’t the Beginning of a Dynasty
The trade for Anthony Davis changed everything.
The Lakers won the 2020 championship, and no one can take that title away from them. Davis was phenomenal defensively, LeBron orchestrated the offense at an elite level, and the roster finally fit around their stars.
But the title wasn’t the start of a dynasty.
It was almost the opposite.
Since winning the championship, the Lakers have won only a handful of playoff series while cycling through constant roster turnover. Injuries, poor asset management, questionable trades, and an aging supporting cast prevented them from building sustained championship contention.
LeBron has continued producing like an All-NBA player, but the team around him has rarely matched that level.
Imagine If He Had Chosen Basketball First
This is where history becomes fascinating.
Imagine 2018 LeBron joining a legitimate contender instead of a rebuilding Lakers team.
Several organizations already had elite young cores, established coaching staffs, and modern roster construction. Plugging arguably the smartest player in NBA history into one of those situations could have produced multiple championships rather than one.
Instead of spending years waiting for a roster to develop, or watching front-office mistakes chip away at championship windows, he could have spent ages 34 through 38 competing for titles every season.
Considering how long he has remained elite, that window turned out to be much larger than anyone expected.
LeBron Probably Didn’t Know How Long His Prime Would Last
It’s easy to criticize the decision with hindsight.
But hindsight is exactly why the conversation exists.
Most NBA legends decline rapidly after age 35.
Even players with legendary longevity, like Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Tim Duncan, and Karl Malone, were no longer carrying offenses the way LeBron still does.
LeBron had every reason to believe 2018 represented the beginning of the final chapter of his career.
He probably thought he had three or four elite seasons remaining before transitioning into more of a complementary role.
Instead, he kept defying aging.
At an age when nearly every superstar in league history had become role players or retired, LeBron remained one of the league’s best creators, scorers, and decision-makers.
If someone had told him in July 2018 that he would still be producing at an All-NBA level eight years later, would he really have prioritized living in Los Angeles over maximizing those championship opportunities?
It’s hard to believe he would have.
The Order Was Backwards
What’s especially interesting is that LeBron’s priorities eventually reversed anyway.
In 2018, he appeared to prioritize life after basketball.
Now, at 41 years old, he’s once again focused on finding the best possible basketball situation to compete for another championship.
In other words, he ended up doing things in reverse.
He went to Los Angeles to begin retirement while he was still one of the most dominant players on the planet.
Years later, after proving he could still compete with the league’s best deep into his 40s, he’s back to thinking about championship situations.
Imagine if those priorities had been flipped.
Spend ages 33 through 39 chasing titles with an already established contender.
Then, once the championship window naturally closed, finish your career in Los Angeles, play in the city you wanted to call home, grow your business empire, and enjoy the final seasons without the pressure of maximizing every remaining championship opportunity.
That sequence makes far more sense knowing what we know today.
Legacy Isn’t Hurt, But Opportunity Was Lost
None of this changes LeBron’s place in history.
Four championships, four MVPs, the all-time scoring record, and over two decades of elite play have already secured one of the greatest careers sports has ever seen.
But greatness also invites questions about what could have been.
The Lakers era delivered one championship, countless memorable performances, and incredible longevity. Yet it also included several seasons where LeBron was still playing like one of the NBA’s best players while carrying flawed, incomplete rosters.
The biggest surprise wasn’t that the Lakers won one championship.
It’s that LeBron remained good enough to realistically contend for several more.
That’s what makes the 2018 decision so fascinating in hindsight. He didn’t waste the end of his career.
He accidentally spent the middle of his championship window preparing for retirement, only to discover that retirement was still years away.
Leave a Reply